Return to the NCHR Homepage

Michele Montas-Dominique
A Note To Jacques Roche

cliquez ici pour la version française

New York, July 21, 2005

Courage, Jacques,

Today, you also are confronted with savagery in that descent into hell that has become our daily lot as a people, a descent into hell that was nonetheless predictable and avoidable, a descent into hell paved with so many stones of impunity.

Your fellow journalists will be standing at your side to say no to the unacceptable just as they said no for Jean Dominique and Brignol Lindor. The difference is that today the unacceptable has become the norm undoubtedly as a result of so many unpunished crimes.

Because you, Jacques, had believed in principles in a Haiti today devoid of law and faith; because you also believed that words could change life, they silenced you with a bullet to the throat and your tongue savagely cut. Silence, they kill.

Because you had the temerity to dream that men and women of good will could contain the onrushing violence, they assassinated you as well.

Today you will be put to rest with belated pomp, you will hear many official promises, and many crocodile tears will be shed on your tortured body. You will hear many promises to investigate. Do not believe too much in them. Your family will demand -- as we did and as the family and colleagues of Brignol Lindor did – the truth, but the investigation will continue forever because too many influential people, under an elected government as well as an interim government – mutatis mutandis – have an interest in protecting impunity.

The “Jacques Roche case” – this is the way they will refer to you – will collect arrest warrants that will not be served. They will find witnesses dead – as they found you – in a street corner and investigating judges will resign out of fear or a sense of powerlessness. You “alleged” murderers will continue to move about freely as with Ti Lou and Gimmy, who were accused of killing Jean Dominique and who, today out of jail, lead their own gangs in total impunity… An even if some day they are tried, your murderers later will probably be exonerated under the justice of the winners of the moment. Courage, Jacques, for at that moment you will need much more courage than you had when you were confronting your torturers.

They will praise you today the better to cover their impotence or refusal to act. Political leaders will shower praise on you and hasten to forget you once the Jacques Roche case ceases to be useful to them. Do not be surprised if they even spit on you should they find it useful to sit down with your murderers. You understand very well the extent to which the culture of forgetfulness, which is the comfortable mirror image of impunity, is nurtured in our country. Courage, Jacques, for you will need much courage to listen to “the words disguised by the wretched to inflame the idiots.”

In the mean time Jacques, when yo see Jean, tell him about the multifaceted violence, the gangrenous corruption, the loss of references, the shoving aside of principles and values, tell him about the bitter struggle for miserable power, and these elections, planned elsewhere, to serve a purpose. Tell him about the country “on the outside” drained of blood and abandoned to its own devices. Tell him about the wind of Maribahoux… But do not forget to tell him, Jacques, about the courage displayed daily by thousands of us, when confronted by savagery, stupidity, cowardice, the courage that you yourself displayed. Tell him about the resistance and tenacious hope. Tell him that your struggle has more than ever meaning and that no murderer can assassinate the dreams of his loved ones and your loved ones. I know that you will understand one another with few words.

Dreams like people put forth new shoots and flowers. And the murderers who roam the city cannot put an end to it. And the time will come for “your dream” to be born again.

Goodbye, my friend.

We will never forget.


Translated by Max Blanchet


NCHR's Strategy

  See also:
  Judicial Reform in Haiti
  La réforme judiciaire en Haïti
Human Rights News
  Archived Human Rights News
  Overview: Mass Expulsions and Deportations
  IACHR Decision of Sep 14, 2000
  CEJIL: Comunicado de prensa
  Related Links
  Campaign Overview
  How You Can Help
   Restavèk: Four-year-old Servants in Haiti - Haiti Insight Dec '96 / Jan '97
  Contact Information
  Open Letter to the Haitian National Police
  Open Letter to the Haitian Minister of Justice
  December 2001 Report
  NCHR Calls on Haiti's President to Ensure Safety of Human Rights Advocates
  NCHR Pays Tribute to Jean Léopold Dominique
  Event Photos
  The Sound of Silence
  more on . . .
    Jean L. Dominique
    Michèle Montas
    Michael S. Hooper

Inter-American Commission on Human Rights: Report on the Situation of Human Rights in Haiti (1994)


Peacebuilding in Haiti: Findings of the International Peace Academy regarding challenges to peacebuilding in Haiti.

  Peace Brigades International, Haiti: Reports from the PBI contingent in Haiti on conflict resolution and political challenges.
  Situation of Human Rights in Haiti: Report of the UN Commission on Human Rights, 1996.
  MICIVIH OEA/ONU: La police nationale d'Haiti et les droits de l'homme
  State Department 1997 Haiti Report
  Haiti Held Hostage
Report of the Watson Institute
  Amnesty International Report
HAITI Steps Forward, Steps Back: Human Rights 10 Years After the Coup (27/09/2001)

Home | About NCHR | Privacy Policy | Contact Us

©2002 NCHR -- ALL RIGHTS RESERVED -- Last updated: 01 May 2007